Appendix D
REP A
EF CON ENDS 13/01/2025 VALID PCD & PPN
From: REDACTED < REDACTED >
Sent: 20 December 2024 18:41
To: EHL Licensing <ehl.licensing@brighton-hove.gov.uk>
Subject: Object for premises license at Hove Kingsway bowling
Dear Sirs
I am the owner of REDACTED
I would like to object to the request to play live music, performances of dance and sell alcohol up to 01.00am every night and Sunday up to 11.00pm.
Selling alcohol up to 01.00pm is very late and could attract members of the public to engage in intimidating groups, unsafe drinking, unacceptable behaviour and recreational drug abuse after the closing hours. This would damage the reputation of a safe neighbourhood.
There is no purpose or benefit to the community to play music and sell alcohol up to this time.
The excessive noise of the music, public and traffic will be harmful to residents. Especially when the premises doors are open and customers spill outside. The increase in traffic fumes will pollute the environment and the banging of car doors could wake children and the elderly. The disturbances are likely to impact the mental health of the neighbourhood. Selling alcohol up to this time every night will encourage anti-social behaviour and disturb the peace. The increase of customers to the premises will attract more vehicles in an over-populated area.
Please take my views into consideration.
Thank you
REDACTED
REP B
EF CON ENDS 13/01/2025 VALID PPN
From: REDACTED < REDACTED >
Sent: 20 December 2024 17:29
To: Emily Fountain < REDACTED >
Subject: Hove Bowling Club Application
Dear Ms Fountain
Planning Application; BH 2022/02830
I am writing to object to the above application made by Hove Bowling Club.
The application goes far beyond that negotiated by REDACTED and the extraordinary hours requested by them for outside drinks and entertainment is far too late.
Outside entertainment and off premises alcohol sales will be a great disturbance to the local residents, especially to those who live REDACTED their club.
We are not willing to accept these planning details, due to the possible noise and excess movement of people in and around the club and area in general.
The area off the beach is residential and to have two clubs literally on top of each other offering drinks and entertainment is totally unacceptable and should not be allowed to be licensed in this way.
I hope you will look at this representation in a positive way and not allow HBC to receive the license they have requested.
If a license is going to be given, it needs to be watered down considerably from what they are requesting.
Thank you
Kind regards
REDACTED
REDACTED
REP C
EF CON ENDS 13/01/2025 VALID PPN
From: REDACTED < REDACTED >
Sent: 30 December 2024 15:25
To: EHL Licensing <EHL.Licensing@brighton-hove.gov.uk>
Subject: Objection to Licence number 2024/05661/LAPRCN
I am writing to you to make formal representation against a licence application.
Licence application number 2024/05661/LAPRCN and/or 1445/3/2024/05661/LAPRCN
Trading name – Hove And Kingsway Bowls
Clubhouse
Outdoor Sports Hub
Kingsway
Hove
BN3 4GP
My name is REDACTED
My address is
REDACTED
Which is REDACTED proposed licenced premises.
I object to the granting of a licence to the Hove Bowls Club for the following reasons and make representation accordingly.
My Concerns
One would expect the licence applicant to be aware of this restriction and to abide by it. The blatant disregard for this restriction does not bode well.
As a resident who will be directly affected by the doubling of noise and alcohol venues with there now being two licenced premises REDACTED instead of the 1 which was in place heretofore, I would have expected the Bowls Club to take these conditions into account. Again the fact that they are riding roughshod over this precedent does not bode well.
i. Live and recorded music until 01:00 every working day is unacceptable especially as the application is for on and off premises.
ii. Live and recorded music on and off premises every Sunday until 23:00 is completely unacceptable in a residential neighbourhood.
iii. There are several families in this building with children who cannot be made to suffer this noise until late at night, 365 days a year.
Regards,
REDACTED
I can be contacted on REDACTED
REP D
EF CON ENDS 13/01/2025 VALID PPN & PCD
From: REDACTED < REDACTED >
Sent: 30 December 2024 16:40
To: EHL Licensing <EHL.Licensing@brighton-hove.gov.uk>
Subject: Objection to licence 1445/3/2024/05661/LAPRCN
Dear Licencing Authority,
I wish to object to the below licence application.
Licence application number 1445/3/2024/05661/LAPRCN
Trading name – Hove and Kingsway Bowls
Clubhouse
Outdoor Sports Hub
Kingsway
Hove
BN3 4GP
My name is REDACTED
My address is
REDACTED
My Concerns are as a property owner and resident of 18 years at the above property and as the person responsible for maintaining the grounds and gardens over the last 12 years.
I have great concerns regarding the noise, security, public urination and light pollution arising from this application.
The Bowls Club thought nothing of pointing their speakers right at our building so the noise could reverberate around the whole building all weekend. Despite complaints they did nothing to modify their behaviour to give some relief to those who have to get up early for work the next day or who have children or those who just want to peacefully enjoy their indoor and outdoor spaces.
This has been a feature of the Bowls Club for years not just during Covid.
We have already come to an agreement with REDACTED regarding their use of outside music so this should apply to the Bowls Club as well.
Regards,
REDACTED
REP E
EF CON ENDS 13/01/2025 VALID PPN
From: REDACTED < REDACTED >
Sent: 02 January 2025 09:22
To: EHL Licensing <EHL.Licensing@brighton-hove.gov.uk>
Subject: RE: Objection to Licence number 2024/05661/LAPRCN
Importance: High
Dear Sir/Madam
I am writing to you to make formal representation against a licence application.
Licence application number 2024/05661/LAPRCN and/or 1445/3/2024/05661/LAPRCN
Trading name – Hove And Kingsway Bowls
Clubhouse
Outdoor Sports Hub
Kingsway
Hove
BN3 4GP
My name is REDACTED
My address is
REDACTED
Which is REDACTED the proposed licenced premises.
I object to the granting of a licence to the Hove Bowls Club for the following reasons and make representation accordingly.
My Concerns
One would expect the licence applicant to be aware of this restriction and to abide by it. The disregard of this restriction is not acceptable.
As a resident who will be directly affected by the doubling of noise and alcohol venues with there now being two licenced premises REDACTED instead of the 1 which was in place heretofore, I would have expected the Bowls Club to take these conditions into account. They are ignoring this precedent which is not acceptable.
i. Live and recorded music until 01:00 every working day is unacceptable especially as the application is for on and off premises.
ii. Live and recorded music on and off premises every Sunday until 23:00 is completely unacceptable in a residential neighbourhood.
iii. There are several families in this building with children who cannot be made to suffer this noise until late at night, 365 days a year.
Regards,
REDACTED
Telephone: REDACTED
Email: REDACTED
REP F
EF CON ENDS 13/01/2025 VALID PPN
From: REDACTED < REDACTED >
Date: Fri, 3 Jan 2025 at 09:14
Subject: Hove & Kingsway Bowls Club Music License Application
To: <EHL.Licesning@brighton-hove.gov.uk>
Hi Licensing Team,
I am writing to object to the application for the music license on the following basis.
Previous complaints about the noise and compliance of the Bowls Club to their music levels licensing conditions have been made about events on the 15 April 2023 and 23 July 2023 and were raised to the Council's Environmental Protection and Licensing Teams. The complaints were serious in nature and consideration was given to engaging Councillors and lawyers to assist.
The Bowls Club has previously made no allowances to ensure that neighbours can enjoy the peace and quiet of their residential addresses and have not adequately addressed concerns raised to staff during events.
I am therefore concerned about the application on the following grounds:
1) The length of time Monday - Saturday 1100 - 01:00 is too late. The timing should be reduced to 22:00 at the latest, taking into account that this is primarily a residential area.
2) The length of time on Sunday's 11:00 - 23:00 is too long and should be reduced to, for example, 20:00.
3) The licensing times should be no greater than other premises in the area, namely REDACTED.
4) Consideration should be given to neighbours wishing to have peace and quiet at the weekends and a long licence on both days does not protect against this.
5) The new facilities offers an opportunity for the Bowls Club to have events inside their new Club room, there is no need for an off-premise license to be granted, which is the main issue related to noise. Other premises, including REDACTED, hold events successfully and within their premises.
6) The Bowls Club has a full roster of events during the Spring/ Summer months giving residents little reprieve from the music levels. A maximum limit of the number of events held should be considered.
7) REDACTED is a new building, well insulated with triple glazing and yet noise levels at times are been intolerable. The new position of the building is closer to older buildings which are unlikely to be as sound proofed and therefore residents will be more sensitive to noise.
Kind Regards
REDACTED
Additional Information received 03/01/2025
From: REDACTED < REDACTED >
Sent: 03 January 2025 17:23
To: EHL Licensing <EHL.Licensing@brighton-hove.gov.uk>; REDACTED <
REDACTED >
Subject: Re: Hove & Kingsway Bowls Club Music License Application
Hi EHL Licensing.
I would also like to make the following points for consideration by the Licensing panel.
As part of the redevelopment of Kingsway, the REDACTED are aware that it is likely that REDACTED and REDACTED will apply for alcohol and music licenses in due course. The extent of the application (times and hours) for the Bowls Club application are therefore objected to on the basis that the number of venues in the locality will increase from one REDACTED to four (REDACTED, REDACTED, Bowls Club and REDACTED) over the next year. As such the licensing application must be managed in line with these other nearby venues. It is requested that due consideration is given to keeping the sports areas primarily as sports facilities and not instead to allow them to become alcohol and music venues and that these activities are contained in the seafront facing venues rather than in premises that face residential buildings.
Consideration must be given to limiting the number of people returning from these venues late at night via neighbouring streets following alcohol consumption and potential disruption as they pass by, numbers of which will surge following the end of events.
Kind Regards
REDACTED
REP G
EF CON ENDS 13/01/2025 VALID PPN
From: REDACTED < REDACTED >
Sent: 06 January 2025 10:09
To: EHL Licensing <EHL.Licensing@brighton-hove.gov.uk>
Subject: Re: Hove and Kingsway Bowling Club
Subject: Hove and Kingsway Bowling Club
Re: Application for Grant of a Premises Licence
I would like to raise concerns about the proposed licensing hours of the Bowls
Clubhouse and, specifically, object to a 1am closing time Monday- Sat and 11pm
on Sunday.
Given that this club is situated in a residential area with many residents
living in apartment blocks and houses nearby, I believe that a closing time
during Monday-Sat of midnight and 10pm on Sunday is far more environmentally
friendly and reasonable given the attendant noise from music, lights and people
leaving the site into the early hours of the morning getting into cars, taxis
etc. When people have had a drink or two the volume of ‘goodbyes’ is always
raised!
Residents REDACTED and nearby will be most affected with these very late night
noise disturbances which may impact their sleep and ability to be up early the
next day for work.
These same residents are already subjected to regular late night weekend music
events at REDACTED; however these finish at midnight which, in my opinion, is
reasonable.
Yours,
REDACTED
email: REDACTED
REP H
EF CON ENDS 13/01/2025 VALID PPN
-----Original Message-----
From: REDACTED < REDACTED >
Sent: 04 January 2025 12:34
To: EHL Licensing <EHL.Licensing@brighton-hove.gov.uk>
Subject: Late licence application Hove and Kingsway Bowling Club
Re: Application for Grant of a Premises Licence
The proposed time are
11:00-01:00 Hrs Mon-Sat
11:00-23:00 Hrs Sun
I would like to raise concerns about the proposed licensing hours of the Bowls Clubhouse and object to a 1am closing time Monday- Thursday.
As the club is situated in a residential area I believe that a closing time Monday-Thursday of midnight is far more reasonable given the noise from music, lights and people leaving the site into the early hours of the morning.
Any residents leaving nearby will be impacted by this level of noise when most of them will be working the next day.
Yours,
REDACTED
REP I
EF CON ENDS 13/01/2025 VALID PPN, PCD & PS
Representation to Licensing Application.
Name & address of premises subject to application.
re Application 1445/3/2024/05661/LAPRCN
Hove & Kingsway Bowling Club,
Outdoor Sports Hub,
Kingsway,
Hove. BN3 4GP
My name and address. (Residence).
REDACTED
The Prevention of Crime and Disorder.
The likelihood of public disorder in this entirely residential stretch of Kingsway will be increased if the extension of the existing hours granted Application No. BH2022/02830. which are adequate in the locality.
(Previously the Bowls Club premises were not open every day and when opened were invariably closed by 21.30 and the members tended to be of the older persons of the community).
The later the availability of alcohol and entertainment, the more likely there will be drunkeness and rowdy behaviour and vandalism on the bowling greens and the newly planted area, around the premises and also on the pavements of Kingsway including the car parking lane.
Public Safety.
Disorderly behaviour is increased later in the evening as can be experienced in Brighton where despite Registered Security Guards, there is frequently aggressive uncontrolled behaviour which threatens public safety particularly to women and minority social groups.
The Prevention of Public Nuisance.
Residents of REDACTED have a problem with male passers by urinating on our property and there is REDACTED of the apartments on REDACTED which are vulnerable REDACTED.
Noise late at night, slamming of car doors and the revving of engines is anticipated.
There is a residents car park to the rear which is misused by non-residents and their guests.
It is likely that Bowls Club members using the facilities of the Sports Hub will be undistinguishable from non members and signing in of members will be totally ineffective.
The result will be that the granted licensing hours will be extended by subterfuge.
The Protection of Children from Harm.
It would be unlikely that unaccompanied or accompanied children would be around the premises at the extended hours of the application at a venue of this kind.
Signed REDACTED 7th January 2025
Name REDACTED
REDACTED
REP J
EF CON ENDS 13/01/2025 VALID PPN
Additional Document signed by 12 residents 2 of which made representation in their own right REP B and REP I.
From: REDACTED < REDACTED >
Sent: 07 January 2025 16:33
To: EHL Licensing <EHL.Licensing@brighton-hove.gov.uk>
Cc: REDACTED < REDACTED >; REDACTED
Subject: Representation for Licence 2024/05661/LAPRCN
Hello, (copy to the Chairman of REDACTED)
Re the licence application by the Hove Bowls Club under number 2024/05661/LAPRCN
I am writing to you as a director of the freehold company which owns the apartment building known as REDACTED.
The freehold is owned by REDACTED Limited a company registered in England under company number REDCATED
The registered address of REDACTED
All of the shareholders in REDACTED own an apartment under leasehold, in the REDACTED building which is located REDACTED the Hove Bowls Club.
The attached document shows the flat numbers and signatures of 12 shareholders/leaseholders and the text of the representations that the freeholder has been asked to make on their behalf to the Licencing Authority as an objection to the above licence application.
Please note that some or all of the signatories may have also made a personal representation but the subject of this representation is specifically the text below.
My name as a director of REDCATED is REDACTED and I can confirm that the residents listed are genuine leaseholders within the building. I also confirm that I have made a separate personal representation as part of the licence application by the Hove Bowls Club.
The text of the representation I, in the capacity of a director of the freehold company am making on behalf of the residents who have signed this petition, is attached but reproduced here for convenience:
To EHL Licensing - ehl.licensing@brighton-hove.gov.uk
Licensing Application - 1445/3/2024/05661/LAPRCN
Hove & Kingsway Bowling Club, Outdoor Sports Hub, Kingsway BN3 4GP
I am a resident of REDACTED and would like the following comments to be taken
into account when considering the above licence application.
The application is for premises with planning permission to operate as a local
community facility (Class F2) in a residential area and any licence granted
should respect this.
The Planning permission, Application No: BH2022/02830, granted in December 2022
states, in Section 27, that ‘The Outdoor Sports Hub premises shall be used as a
café/restaurant and local community facilities (Use Class E(b) and Class F.2)
only and for no other purpose’.
Section 31 of the permission states: The Outdoor Sports Hub premises hereby
permitted shall not be in use by customers except between the hours of 08:00
and 00:00 on Mondays to Sundays, including Bank or Public Holidays. Reason: To
safeguard the amenities of the locality and to comply with policies DM20 and
DM40 of Brighton & Hove City Plan Part 2.
The following limitations and conditions are suggested as suitable and
appropriate.
l The application includes operating hours until 01.00
from Monday to Saturday which is outside that granted by the planning
permission. Permission to operate after 00.00 should therefore not be granted.
l Sale of alcohol should be limited to Club Members and
their guests who have been ‘signed in’.
l Patrons should not be permitted to carry drinking
vessels outside after 23.00.
l Music, both live and recorded, should only be played
inside the building, there should be no speakers in any outside area.
l Music should not be audible at any nearby residential
building after 22.00.
If any further information is required please let me know.
Yours faithfully,
REDACTED
REP K
EF CON ENDS 13/01/2025 VALID PPN
From: REDACTED < REDACTED >
Sent: 09 January 2025 00:22
To: EHL Licensing <EHL.licensing@brighton-hove.gov.uk>
Subject: ++Hove & Kingsway Bowling Club (‘the bowling club’) licence
application
I am writing to object to the licence application which the bowling club has submitted and which seeks to permit live music and entertainment alongside the sale and supply of alcohol (on and off premises) until 1am six nights a week in a residential area. I own a flat in the REDACTED at REDACTED which looks out over Kingsway and the new Hove Beach Park.
Previous events at the bowling club have resulted in serious complaints from local residents about the noise (in particular the music levels) which have been raised to the Council’s Environmental Protection and Licensing Teams. No allowances have been made to take account of the proximity of their neighbours and concerns raised to the bowling club staff during such events have not been satisfactorily addressed. Specifically:
- the music levels have been too loud
- the music continues too often too late into the night
- the sale of alcohol into the early hours compounds the noise and impact on local residents
- customers dispersing after events (and resultant noise from cars, taxis etc) extends the disturbance
None of the above is appropriate in a residential area where neighbours need to be up early the following mornings to work. And how can the sale of alcohol off premises be appropriate in such an area? The playing of music and the sale of alcohol should not be permitted past 10pm and the number of events carefully limited.
It is unclear how the bowling club’s licence application sits alongside the licence recently granted to REDACTED within the new sporting hub. Are both organisations not operating within the same building? Whether within the same premises or adjacent, the requirements relating to the prevention of public nuisance as regards local residents must apply equally. In particular the conditions contained in Annex 2 (conditions consistent with the operating schedule) of the licence granted to REDACTED must apply equally to the operation of the bowling club including but not limited to
- all outside speakers facing south (towards the sea) and being turned off at 10pm
- no amplified live music to be played outside of the venue
- outside seating closing at 10pm
- outside lighting not to cause a light nuisance and to be switched off at 10pm
The new Hove Beach Park should be focused on the provision of local sports
facilities and not on alcohol and music venues to the detriment of local
residents. Activities focused on alcohol and music should be contained in the
seafront facing venues and not in premises that face onto residential buildings.
Regards
REDACTED
REDACTED
REDACTED